Answering a large questions around Deshaun Watson’s injury

9:55 PM ET


If you’re an NFL fan with a pulse, your heart sank a bit on Thursday as we review about Deshaun Watson going down for a residue of a deteriorate with a ripped ACL. Every repairs is bad, of course, nonetheless Watson competence unequivocally good have been a many pleasing warn of an often-dour 2017 season. As an sparkling immature actor personification in a city that has been on a drum coaster by tragedy to a fun of Wednesday night’s World Series victory, there competence be no actor in a joining that neutral fans would have wanted to see stay healthy some-more than Clemson’s inhabitant champion quarterback.

Watson’s repairs raises all kinds of questions. Let’s try to answer a few of them here.

Is there a unreasonable of injuries going around a NFL this season?

It’s formidable to say. The rubbing rate in a NFL is remarkably and frustratingly high on a year-to-year basis, nonetheless it’s satisfactory to consternation if this deteriorate seems quite bad. As we mentioned while recording my podcast with Mina Kimes, all we need to do to suppose an repairs predicament in a NFL is to watch one or dual blurb breaks during an NFL game. You’re firm to see ads with Odell Beckham Jr., Aaron Rodgers and J.J. Watt, dual of whom are finished for a year with a other out indefinitely (Rodgers).

In terms of quarterbacks, let’s try to contextualize a problem. As of Week 9, there are 6 starting signal-callers on a shelf: Watson, Rodgers, Sam Bradford, Andrew Luck, Carson Palmer and Ryan Tannehill. Jay Cutler, stuffing in for Tannehill, would validate as a seventh if he’s incompetent to play Sunday.

That’s a high number, nonetheless not remarkably so. Last deteriorate in Week 9, for example, 4 starting quarterbacks were out injured: Cutler, Robert Griffin, Tony Romo and Alex Smith, a latter of whom would lapse a following week. At this time 10 years ago, in a 2007 deteriorate hold adult as a rise of football, 6 would-be starters were out of a lineup. A 1988 Washington Post essay angry about a miss of accessible quarterbacks remarkable how 18 passers had left down with injuries by a finish of Week 6, nonetheless some of them were not starters.

Strictly as a passer, Watson was fifth in passer rating and seventh in a joining in ANY/A, nonetheless even that sells him short. He had drawn 8 pass multiplication calls for a league-leading 173 yards of dark offense. Watson had thrown 8 interceptions, nonetheless many of them had come in irrelevant or destroyed situations, as 5 of them altered Houston’s win outlook by 2.4 percent or less.

Watson threw 204 passes before pang his knee repairs in use on Thursday. We have to adjust quarterback stats for a epoch in that they came, that Pro Football Reference does with a index statistics, as 100 represents era-adjusted league-average.

Ninety-eight quarterbacks have thrown 200 passes or some-more during their entrance campaigns given a merger. Of those 98 passers, Watson posted a best touchdown commission index (152), a fourth-best yards per try index (124), and a ninth-best practiced yards per try index (113). The closest rookie quarterback Watson resembles is Mark Rypien, who was indeed creation his entrance in 1988 after dual seasons on harmed reserve. Rypien started 6 games during his rookie campaign, and their era-adjusted stats are remarkably similar:

Rypien was already 27 by a time he took over as a full-time starter and unequivocally spent usually 5 years as a full-time No. 1 quarterback, nonetheless he finished it to dual Pro Bowls and won Super Bowl MVP for his exploits in heading Washington to a Super Bowl in 1991 during those 5 years in D.C. Watson has shown identical ability in terms of formulating large plays downfield, nonetheless he’s distant some-more effective as a runner.

Watson’s touchdown commission would have regressed to a meant over a incomparable sample, nonetheless given how both he and a Texans’ offense were improving week after week, it seems expected a rest of his diversion would have kept up. It’s unfit to make a ideal comparison since of a smaller sample, nonetheless Watson’s debate is positively in line with that of good new rookies like Prescott, Matt Ryan, and Russell Wilson as among a best in football.

Does this impact his long-term future?

It’s too early to say, nonetheless quarterbacks have been means to lapse from ACL tears nonetheless any important dump off in performance. This is a second time Watson has ripped an ACL after doing so in college, nonetheless that was an repairs to his left knee, while this repairs is to his right knee. The earnest news is that we haven’t listened anything about repairs over a ACL, that should diminution a complexity of Watson’s rehab.

Barring serve news on a injury, it seems expected Watson will be prepared to lapse in time for Week 1 subsequent season. While fans competence consider about Robert Griffin as a worrisome comp for Watson, given that Griffin looked shining as a rookie before going down with a knee repairs and unwell to live adult to his prior heights, there are some-more certain comparables for mobile quarterbacks of a past, too. Randall Cunningham tore his ACL in 1991 and remained effective as both a passer and curtain on returning. Rich Gannon compulsory an ACL correct after going down with a knee repairs as a backup in 1988, and a destiny Raiders standout remained an effective scrambler, nonetheless he didn’t see critical diversion time until 1990.

Should a Texans keep Watson from using as frequently when he returns?

I consider Watson would be means to attain nonetheless a hazard of a read-option by trait of his ability as a pristine passer, nonetheless we also don’t see any reason to dramatically change a offense in an try to keep Watson healthy. Watson’s ACL tears have both come in practice; this many new repairs saw him go down nonetheless being touched. If he was removing harmed as a scrambler in games, it competence be a opposite story, nonetheless a Texans shouldn’t need to put any restraints on Watson when he returns.

How most of a dump off is there from Watson to Tom Savage?

Obviously, there’s an huge disproportion between Watson and a quarterback he took over for after a gloomy Week 1. Savage has nonetheless to uncover any pointer that he’s expected to spin a efficient NFL quarterback. The former Pittsburgh and Rutgers passer unsuccessful to uncover pro-level correctness as an amateur, and his 105 pro passes have constructed a passer rating of 73.9, scarcely 30 points worse than Watson’s 103.0 mark. Furthermore, it’s revelation that a Texans drafted Savage in 2014 and nonetheless regularly looked outward a classification to supplement Brock Osweiler and afterwards Watson in lieu of giving Savage a starting job.

The evident impact in Vegas was significant. The line for Houston’s Sunday diversion opposite a Colts during a Westgate Las Vegas sportsbook changed by 5.5 points, with a Texans 12.5-point favorites before a Watson repairs and seven-point favorites after. Houston was 40-1 to win their initial championship before a Watson injury, nonetheless they were forsaken to 100-1 once news broke.

Should a Texans pointer another quarterback?

They already have, during slightest as an puncture measure. Savage was a usually other quarterback on a active roster, as Brandon Weeden was cut after training stay and hold on with a Titans. Bill O’Brien went behind to his Penn State days and sealed former Raider Matt McGloin, who played underneath O’Brien in State College during a 2012 season. McGloin posted a 75.3 passer rating over 4 years as a Raiders backup, throwing 11 picks on what amounts to about a half-season’s value of pass attempts.

The name that will fundamentally cocktail adult in tie with this vacancy, of course, is Colin Kaepernick. If we lived in a universe in that NFL owners were behaving rationally, a Texans would have already sealed Kaepernick to fill in. McGloin and Savage haven’t been effective in any NFL complement and don’t have anything imitative a athleticism compulsory to attain in a offense O’Brien has commissioned with Watson, that has employed read-option concepts from Watson’s playbook during Clemson.

Those ideas need a quarterback to be a hazard to run and a ability to chuck downfield, both of that Kaepernick can do. Much has been finished of Kaepernick’s ostensible inability to chuck in a pocket, nonetheless his career passer rating in a slot is 90.3, absolutely improved than that of Savage (79.8) or McGloin (78.3). Watson also spent copiousness of time piracy and scrambling out of a pocket. The rookie threw 45 passes outward of a slot before going down, second-most in a joining behind Russell Wilson.

Two obstacles mount in a approach of Kaepernick, who O’Brien called “a good football player” in March. One is Kaepernick’s ongoing collusion lawsuit opposite a league. The other is a participation of owners Bob McNair, who desirous a near-mutiny within a Texans’ locker room by referring to a league’s players as “inmates” during a assembly with players in New York City.

It’s maybe revelation that Texans players radically allocated left tackle Duane Brown as their deputy in light of McNair’s comments, usually for Houston to subsequently understanding Brown to a Seahawks during a trade deadline in lieu of giving their longtime left tackle a agreement extension. Could McNair move himself to pointer Kaepernick? Would McNair try to pointer Kaepernick in an try to correct his name? Would Kaepernick even be peaceful to play for an owners who finished such an unresponsive remark? We’ll see in a weeks to come, nonetheless there’s no football-related reason to play Savage, McGloin, or any other accessible quarterback over Kaepernick.

Can a Texans still win a AFC South?

Even with Watson, Houston’s chances of claiming a third true multiplication pretension weren’t great. The Texans were 3-4 and a diversion behind of both a Jaguars and Titans in a AFC South, with a Jaguars holding a head-to-head tiebreaker over Houston after that blowout in Week 1. According to a Football Power Index, a Texans had only a 29.7 percent possibility of creation a playoffs and a 12.4 percent of winning their division.

Those local titles have come with Brian Hoyer (who substantially wouldn’t have returned to Houston even if a Watson repairs had come before he sealed with a Patriots) and Osweiler as primary quarterbacks, so it’s frequency as if a Texans have indispensable good quarterback play to succeed. The disproportion between those teams and this one, of course, is injuries on defense. The Texans are already nonetheless Watt and Whitney Mercilus, who are finished for a year. Brian Cushing is dangling until Week 14, and deputy Dylan Cole is already out Sunday.

Houston’s invulnerability has still tender for stretches this deteriorate — it ranks eighth in DVOA — nonetheless it has played what amounts to scarcely 3 games nonetheless Watt and Mercilus. With a dual star corner rushers going down early opposite a Chiefs, a Houston invulnerability authorised Alex Smith and a Kansas City offense to measure 35 points. The Texans afterwards hold a squalid Browns to 14 points, nonetheless a Seahawks exploded for 34 some-more points on offense in their classical win over Houston on Sunday.

O’Brien will expected delayed down a gait with Savage in a lineup, anticipating to win by using a turn and personification sound invulnerability with a guys he has left. Anything is possible, nonetheless a Texans have mislaid dual of their best players over a past week with Brown and Watson no longer in a lineup, that will dramatically impact their using game. Unless their invulnerability takes a large jump brazen from what we’ve seen opposite non-Browns competition, it’s tough to find a trail in that a Texans contest for a multiplication title.

Who does a Watson repairs help?

Obviously, while nobody wants to see a star quarterback get injured, Watson’s deficiency could spin a AFC South into a conflict between a Jaguars and Titans. The other group in line to advantage from a Watson repairs is a Browns, that acquired Houston’s 2018 first-round collect in a trade that netted a Browns Watson in a initial place. Cleveland also binds Houston’s second-round collect as partial of a Osweiler income dump. Those picks looked expected to come toward a second half of a initial round, nonetheless with Savage replacing Watson, a Browns could fitness their approach into another top-10 pick.


Do you have an unusual story to tell? E-mail stories@tutuz.com