Controversy surrounds abortions for Downs syndrome in Iceland

A new essay from CBS News proclaims that “few countries have come as tighten to eradicating Down syndrome births as Iceland.” The user word here is “births.”


Has Iceland discovered, by some groundbreaking record and research, a heal to a chromosomal abnormality? No. How do we “disappear Down syndrome” then, as one of a article’s taglines states? You “disappear” people with Down syndrome.

“Iceland isn’t indeed expelling Down syndrome. They’re usually murdering everybody that has it. Big difference,” tweeted singer Patricia Heaton, who has been outspoken about her pro-life beliefs.

“There is zero to applaud in Iceland’s ‘eradication’ of babies innate with Down syndrome by abortion,” stressed Jor-El Godsey, boss of Heartbeat International, a network of 1,800 pro-life predicament pregnancy centers that warn women and bond them with resources via a country.

“These are altered tellurian beings hand-crafted in a design of God, and no supervision or chairman on earth has a management to sack persons with Down syndrome of their lives,” Godsey told CNA. “Down syndrome is not a genocide sentence, and it is grievous to advise otherwise.”

Every profound lady in Iceland is given an choice of a prenatal exam that can detect Down syndrome with 85 percent accuracy. “Nearly 100 percent” of pregnancies that tested certain for Down syndrome were aborted, CBS reports.

The fact-checking site Snopes adds an critical gift to a picture.

“The Icelandic supervision does not charge abortions for mothers whose unborn children exam certain for Down syndrome, nor do they charge that a mom is compulsory to take a exam in a initial place,” they state.

Snopes records that Hulda Hjartardottir, conduct of a Prenatal Diagnosis Unit during Landspitali University Hospital, in that around 70 percent of Icelandic children are born, told CBS News that “babies with Down syndrome are still being innate in Iceland.”

While prenatal contrast is not compulsory in Iceland, medical providers tell any profound lady that a exam is an option. The country, that has a race of 330,000, customarily sees usually one or dual children a year innate with Down syndrome – mostly a result, a essay reports, of inadequate testing.

Other countries “aren’t lagging too distant behind” in Down syndrome termination rates, a essay states. “The United States has an estimated (abortion) rate for Down syndrome of 67 percent (1995-2011); in France it’s 77 percent (2015); and Denmark, 98 percent (2015).”

The CBS essay enclosed some contention of a reliable dilemmas that prenatal screening and termination of babies with Down syndrome present.

Geneticist Kari Stefansson pronounced for a piece, “My bargain is that we have fundamentally eradicated, almost, Down syndrome from a multitude – that there is frequency ever a child with Down syndrome in Iceland anymore.”

But when asked what this means for society, he cautioned: “It reflects a comparatively clumsy genetic counseling. And we don’t consider that clumsy genetic conversing is desirable…You’re carrying impact on decisions that are not medical, in a way.

“I don’t consider there’s anything wrong with determined to have healthy children, yet how distant we should go in seeking those goals is a sincerely difficult decision,” he said.

The essay also admits that while people innate with Down syndrome are during risk for several other health problems, many people with Down syndrome also live full and healthy lives, and are means to live exclusively or semi-independently, reason jobs, and have relationships.

“Many people innate with Down syndrome can live full, healthy lives, with an normal lifespan of around 60 years.”

Perhaps a best evidence opposite a expulsion of Down syndrome is Augusta, a lovable small seven-year-old pink-clad lady peering out from a pages of a CBS article. Her mother, Thordis Ingadottir, took a exam when she was profound with Augusta, yet it unsuccessful to detect Down syndrome.

Now, Ingadottir has turn an disciple for people with Down syndrome.

“I will wish that she will be entirely integrated on her possess terms in this society. That’s my dream,” Ingadottir told CBS. “Isn’t that a simple needs of life? What kind of multitude do we wish to live in?”

Godsey told CNA that relatives whose children have Down syndrome or other genetic abnormalities need adore and support – not abortion.

“(These parents)…deserve adore and support that will advantage their flourishing families, and termination fails definitely to broach on a fake promises to advantage families, people and multitude as a whole,” he said.

Godsey combined that roughly anyone who knows someone with Down syndrome would be totally opposite a elimination.

“As anyone who knows a chairman with Down syndrome can tell you, these pleasing people are an comprehensive fun to their families and communities. The universe grows exponentially poorer as we kill trusting babies for a ‘crime’ of unwell to compare adult to a self-aggrandizing expectations.”

The fun of life with a family member who has Down syndrome was distinguished by CBS in a opposite article, published to symbol World Down Syndrome Day in 2015. It was a mainstay by Marguerite (Maggie) Reardon, a comparison author during CNET, about when she found out her daughter would be innate with Down syndrome.

For a prolonged time, she deliberate abortion, yet her father was opposite it. What altered her mind was a day she found a village of other people with Down syndrome and relatives of children with Down syndrome.

She’s still an exhausted, stressed out parent, she wrote, yet that’s not since her child has Down syndrome. It’s since she has dual small kids who keep her busy.

“It’s loyal my daughter has some developmental delays. And she receives a brood of therapies by Early Intervention to assistance keep her on track,” she said.

“But she’s also wonderful. She has a wink in her eye and an spreading laugh that creates even a many miserable looking people on a transport grin when she stares them down. When she puts her conduct on my shoulder as we stone her to nap any night, my heart melts no matter what kind of day I’ve had.

“I do consider she is some-more special than other children, yet it’s not since she has Down syndrome. It’s since I’m a totally inequitable and doting mom who thinks no one could presumably be as adorable, splendid or humorous as my possess child,” she wrote. “And her name is Margot.”

Crux Staff contributed to this report.


Do you have an unusual story to tell? E-mail stories@tutuz.com