Missing pieces: What Microsoft unsuccessful to broach in a Windows 10 Creators Update

If a Windows 10 Creators Update had worked out as Microsoft had promised, we all would be holding 3D selfies, importing them to Windows, and afterwards pity them among a closest friends and coworkers around Office presentations and mixed-reality headsets.


Microsoft sole us that vision as partial of a Creators Update launch final fall. But somewhere between afterwards and a Creators Update rollout proclamation Apr 29, pivotal pieces went missing. Microsoft before pronounced that a My People knowledge would be left for a “Redstone 3” refurbish in a fall. The association never warned us, however, that we wouldn’t see a Windows Capture app, that creates 3D objects simply by drumming your smartphone. If there’s a approach to share 3D objects within a Holotour app within a HoloLens, we haven’t seen it. And, of course, conjunction a HoloLens nor a third-party mixed-reality inclination are commercially accessible yet.

The mocking thing about a Windows 10 Creators Update is that, even lacking all that, it’s arguably a many poignant refurbish given a launch of Windows 10. Those facilities that done it into a shipping code, including diversion streaming, e-reading, Game Mode, Beam streaming, Game Mode, and dozens more, collectively elevate a Creators Update

But it could have been so most more.

Missing: Capture 3D, 3D PowerPoint, HoloTour

Over a final few weeks, we found myself obsessing over one elementary statement. The really initial underline that Microsoft introduced during a exhibit of a Creators Update final tumble was this judgment of 3D content. Microsoft’s Megan Saunders walked on theatre and announced that, in a Creators Update, “3D is for everyone.”

“If we truly wish to make 3D for everyone,” Saunders said,” afterwards we need to make 3D origination as elementary as holding a print or a video on your phone.”

windows constraint video Youtube / Microsoft

3D calm constraint with Windows Capture 3D looks so easy.

Saunders afterwards churned out an HP Elite x3 Windows phone, launched what she called a Windows Capture 3D experience, and walked around a tiny indication of a silt palace as a app clearly assembled a 3D model, live, on her phone, in seconds. Voila: real-world object, Microsoft app, 3D construct. Cue a applause. 

Watch the video  for yourself to see how elementary Saunders done it look. Tell me that app doesn’t demeanour prepared to ship, especially as she clearly uses it live on stage. But no, it’s not available. Was Saunders’ opening sleight of hand? A movie? Did Microsoft reason behind Capture 3D until it could be prepared on Android and iOS as well? Microsoft hasn’t said.

3D indicate fiasco IDG / Mark Hachman

Trying to indicate this wooden horse’s conduct took hours to set adult and configure a Kinect with a Windows 10 3D Scan app…

What creates that matter so critical is that, Paint 3D aside, scanning real-world objects into Windows is roughly ludicrously difficult. (Unless you’re regulating an HP Sprout.) You’ll need Microsoft’s 3D Scan app, a PC with a decent GPU, a Kinect abyss camera, a large adapter, some arrange of rotating table, a tutorial, and a good understanding of patience. we spent several hours, muttering and cursing, and got something that looked like a drifting urn holding a dump. Brian Posey, a Microsoft MVP, attempted out 3D Scan for Redmond Magazine and gave adult median through

3d builder screwup 2 IDG / Mark Hachman

…And all we finished adult with is this mess.

It goes on from there. As partial of a launch event, Microsoft’s Heather Alekson introduced the ability to import 3D objects into PowerPoint and other Office apps. To date, that underline isn’t accessible possibly in Office or in a Office Insider program. Paint 3D within a HoloLens? Importing 3D objects into a practical space? Neither, apparently, is here. Microsoft tells me that “Windows Mixed Reality [formerly famous as Windows Holographic] will be accessible on Windows 10 PCs with a Creators Update so that developers can start formulating content,” implying that unchanging users will have to wait for access.

acer windows churned existence growth book headset Microsoft

A digest of a Acer Mixed Reality Developer Edition headset.

We can’t omit a miss of mixed-reality devices, either. Yes, a shortcoming for delivering mixed-reality inclination on time for a launch of a Windows Creators Update falls on hardware partners like Acer, Asus, and Dell. (Did Microsoft’s Terry Myerson guarantee mixed-reality inclination by a Creators Update launch? Decide for yourself.) But Microsoft has grown a possess hardware for years, and has a parsimonious operative attribute with any of these vendors. 3D-capable, mixed-reality hardware was partial of Microsoft’s 3D vision, and it hasn’t been delivered. 

The gaping holes in Microsoft’s 3D prophesy shroud all else Microsoft betrothed final fall. But a series of other facilities Microsoft betrothed for a Creators Update haven’t appeared, either.

Missing: My People

Microsoft already sensitively announced that it’s postponing a My People experience. My People, that sounds like it competence be possibly replacing or supplementing a existent People app within Windows 10, will concede we to collect 5 tighten friends or family members and customize your practice around them—putting icons in a taskbar, auto-suggesting them as email contacts and to chat, and permitting them to send we emoji around what Microsoft calls “shoulder taps”.

my people Windows 10 Creators Update IDG

My People: a casulaty of a Microsoft growth process.

Microsoft, though, skeleton to reason My People for “the subsequent vital refurbish to Windows,” that is due out in a fall.

Missing: Xbox Arenas

One of a facilities Microsoft showed off in a Xbox gaming space (which has a possess Creators Update rolling out now) was Arenas, player-configured tournaments. “The Xbox group is still operative tough to move tradition gamer-created Arena tournaments to a Xbox community, yet it will not be releasing alongside a Windows 10 Creators Update,” Microsoft pronounced in a statement.

Missing: Groove Music Maker

Though it was never strictly announced, a Groove Music mixer app seemed in a “sizzle reel” of other Windows 10 CU facilities during a launch itself, as good as Microsoft’s ubiquitous Windows 10 Creators Update video. we haven’t seen it in a Windows 10 CU itself, nor a Microsoft Store. 

groove song builder Windows 10 Creators Update Youtube / Microsoft

Microsoft member pronounced that they had “nothing to share” about a predestine of Groove Music Maker.

Missing: Tabs as Reminders

One of a intelligent facilities that Microsoft combined early to a Windows 10 CU was a ability to tie an Edge add-on to a Cortana reminder, a accessible jumping-off indicate to investigate a marriage cake, try intensity campgrounds, or puncture by taxation regulations. In November, though, a association canceled it.

I’m wakeful that companies over-promise and under-deliver, check products and cancel commitments. Sometimes they only slip into a niche and never recover. You know these names: Half-Life 3, Duke Nukem Forever, HD DVD, StrongARM, a Itanium chipMarket final change.

Simply incompatible My People or Capture 3D or Arenas from a Creators Update positively doesn’t meant that we’ll never see them again. I’m betting we’ll hear most some-more about churned existence in a month or so during Build, as a run-up to Windows’ subsequent vital refurbish this fall. we pronounced it in my examination and I’ll contend it again, though: I’d call a subsequent “Redstone 3” recover a “Windows 10 Creators Update 2.” It’s a mouthful, though it’s also an critical approach for Microsoft to save face.


Do you have an unusual story to tell? E-mail stories@tutuz.com