Trump’s Anti-Obama Eclipse Meme Doesn’t Make Scientific Sense

President Trump is a best moon in a whole solar system. He has a biggest craters—beautiful, pleasing craters—and a softest lunar dust. The reporters who cover him don’t have such soothing dust. Sad!

You competence never have suspicion of Donald Trump as a moon—a huge, oblivious mass, perpetually cursed to repeat a same cycles day after day, year after year. OK, maybe we have. But possibly way, Trump apparently thinks of himself usually that way. In a center of a 56-minute Tweet shout this morning, a President retweeted this image, display his smiling, full-color face solemnly eclipsing a grim, black-and-white design of former President Barack Obama. The heading on a design reads, “The best obscure ever!”

It’s never terribly easy to parse Presidential tweets. This one is even worse than most, given there are so many conflicting approaches we could take. There’s indifference: Trump’s retweet finger is a finely honed instrument, designed for speed, not discernment. He sees it, he likes it, he retweets it. The male is busy, after all.

There’s exhaustion: The eclipse? The eclipse? We’re now politicizing a eye-widening, soul-stirring, kumbaya-fest that was a sum solar eclipse? Feel giveaway to go distortion down in a darkened room if you’d like. The front table will call we in 2020.


Then, of course, there’s a scientific—and this is maybe one Trump should have suspicion about a small bit some-more than he apparently did. Eclipses occur since each now and then, in predicted though still primally unsettling cycles, a warm, bright, life-giving intent is vaporous by a dark, dead, inanimate rock. The stone is tiny—400 times smaller than a big, splendid thing. But it’s also 400 times closer, so it appears many bigger than it is—its distance and significance a small apparition of proximity.

This certainly isn’t where President Trump wanted to go, though hey, once we entice scholarship to a cooking party, we don’t get to ask it to leave usually since we don’t like a jokes it’s telling. So let’s cruise too that it is during an obscure that a object in some ways shows itself many brightly. It’s not a black hoop that a moon creates during a impulse of assemblage that transfixes us so—that’s usually a hole in a sky. It’s a luminosity of a solar corona—the deceive of illuminated gasses that tide millions of miles into space. Try to demeanour during a object during any other time and it’s an practice in pain and gawk aversion. Look during it during an eclipse, and it’s a dark object—in this box Obama—not a obscuring one, that knocks your hosiery off.

The President’s opponents are not above usually this kind of semiotic misfire. The obscure meme Trump retweeted echoed a some-more slapdash entrance from his opponents, with a smiling Obama relocating in front of a snarling Trump and content that read, “The usually obscure we unequivocally wanna see.”

No matter a sold meme, both sides should remember that it’s probable to go too distant down a science-as-metaphor road. Start articulate about a quantum enigma of lifting a debt roof and building a limit wall, or a Newtonian movement of flitting Obamacare giving arise to a equal and conflicting greeting of perplexing to dissolution it, and you’re really going to remove a room. (The one difference to this rule: Feel giveaway to call anyone or anything during all a boson. Bosons are always funny.)

All a same, distinct many presidential tweets, there’s something to be schooled from Thursday morning’s small offering, supposing we demeanour during it a right way. Science is a slow, patient, iterative process, in that critical people work really tough to arrive during fugitive truths and suggestive results—results that mostly make a universe a many improved place. Politics, finished right, ought to be a same thing. In a White House that has turn a ruling homogeneous of a groundwork lab, it competence be time for a small of a strictness a genuine scientists request each day.

Jeffrey Kluger is Editor during Large for TIME repository and a author of Apollo 8.

Do you have an unusual story to tell? E-mail