Tulsa cop Betty Jo Shelby not guilty in death of Terence Crutcher

A jury has declared police officer Betty Jo Shelby not guilty of manslaughter after she shot and killed Terence Crutcher. 

After hearing closing arguments in Shelby’s trial Wednesday morning, jurors had deliberated since noon, taking just over nine hours to arrive at the verdict for the killing that sparked nationwide outrage.

The victim’s father, Rev. Joey Crutcher, told media outside the courtroom that Shelby “got away with murder.”

The jury’s makeup was eight women, four men, with nine white people and three black people, according to the Tulsa World. At least four of the jurors broke down in tears as they left the courtroom.

Officials discuss racism in cop’s shooting of unarmed black man

The Rev. Joey Crutcher, father of Terence Crutcher, talks with the media following the verdict. At left is Leanna Crutcher, the mother of Terence Crutcher and at right is Crutcher family attorney Damario Solomon-Simmons. At right rear is Terence's twin sister, Tiffany Crutcher.

The Rev. Joey Crutcher, father of Terence Crutcher, talks with the media following the verdict. At left is Leanna Crutcher, the mother of Terence Crutcher and at right is Crutcher family attorney Damario Solomon-Simmons. At right rear is Terence’s twin sister, Tiffany Crutcher.

(Sue Ogrocki/AP)

“This was a very difficult case with lots of difficult issues,” Judge Doug Drummond said before the decision was announced. “I hope everyone can acknowledge that.”

He added, “I’m asking you to trust the system.”

Following the announcement of the verdict, a group of people protesting the decision to let Shelby walk free approached the front door of the Mayo Hotel to demand the officer come out, the protesters apparently under the impression Shelby was inside. 

MANDATORY CREDIT; KOTV OUT; KJRH OUT; KTUL OUT; KOKI OUT; KQCW OUT; KDOR OUT; TULSA OUT; TULSA WEBSITES OUT

Protestors gathered in front of the Mayo Hotel after a not guilty verdict for Betty Jo Shelby is announced at the Tulsa County Courthouse. Oklahoma’s Republican Gov. Mary Fallin called for calm in the wake of the decision.

(Ian Maule/Tulsa World via AP)

As a pastor began to address the crowd, protesters moved out into the street, blocking traffic on Denver Avenue, the Tulsa World reported. 

Tulsa cop who killed Terence Crutcher says he caused shooting

Police issued a warning that “chemical agents will be used” if the group didn’t leave. 

Finally, around 12:20 a.m. Thursday, the line of protesters broke and people began to leave the area. 

In their closing arguments, prosecutors noted that the other officers around her knew it was a “bad shoot” after she killed the unarmed man.

Shelby stopped after seeing Crutcher, a 40-year-old father of four, in the middle of a road on Sept. 16, opening fire after he refused commands to lie down.

The officer, 43, has claimed she believed that the motorist, whose hands were seen up in video of the shooting, may have been reaching into his car for a gun.

UNDATED PHOTO; BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE; AP PROVIDES ACCESS TO THIS THIRD PARTY PHOTO SOLELY TO ILLUSTRATE NEWS REPORTING OR COMMENTARY ON FACTS DEPICTED IN IMAGE; MUST BE USED WITHIN 14 DAYS FROM TRANSMISSION; NO ARCHIVING; NO LICENSING; MANDATORY CREDIT

Terence Crutcher (right), shown with his twin sister Tiffany Crutcher, was shot and killed by Shelby in September.

(Courtesy of Crutcher Family/Parks Crump, LLC via AP)

She has also claimed Crutcher appeared to be high, with a vial of PCP found in his car and the drug found in his system during an autopsy.

However, no gun was found, and prosecutors say he posed no threat to officers and did nothing aggressive.

Shelby, who also said that she relied on her training when deciding to shoot rather than use a Taser, said in an interview last month that Crutcher caused his own death.

HANDOUT EDITORIAL USE ONLY/NO SALES

Crutcher’s hands were seen up in video of the shooting.

(TULSA POLICE DEPARTMENT/EPA)

However, Tulsa County District Attorney Steve Kunzweiler said that other officers knew the shooting was wrong immediately afterwards, with a fellow cop telling Shelby “not to say a word.”

The officer potentially faced life in prison had she been convicted.

With News Wire Services

Tags: terence crutcher police shootings gun violence Send a Letter to the Editor Join the Conversation: facebook Tweet


Do you have an unusual story to tell? E-mail stories@tutuz.com